Interview feedback questions for hiring managers: example and template

7 min readUpdated November 2026The Sorinai team

What to ask a hiring manager after each interview, and how to pass the answers on to the candidate, with a worked example and a free Word interview feedback template.

What is interview feedback from a hiring manager?

Interview feedback is what the hiring manager concluded from an interview and why: whether the candidate goes through, and the evidence for and against them. In-house, it often comes through a form in the applicant tracking system. In an agency, it usually comes on a call: the recruiter rings the hiring manager after each interview and passes what they said on to the candidate.

A man with short black hair and tortoiseshell glasses, in a dark jacket over a patterned shirt, listens on a mobile phone in a bright office, with a window behind him and green binders on a shelf.
The best time for the feedback call is within a few hours of the interview, while the hiring manager still remembers the detail. Photo: Felicity Tai, Pexels.

The call matters more than it looks. The hiring manager's reasons are what the next interview tests and what the candidate will ask you about. A verdict with no reasons can't do either job.

It isn't the same as the interviewers' own interview notes, which record what the candidate said. The feedback is the judgement they made from them.

What questions should you ask for interview feedback?

Ask in this order: the verdict, then the reasons, then what happens next.

The verdict

  • Would you like to see them again, or are they a no?
  • How sure are you?

The must-haves

Take the must-haves you agreed at the intake meeting and ask about each one:

  • What did you see for [the must-have]? Can you give me an example from the interview?
  • Where was the evidence thin?

What impressed them

  • What stood out? What did they say or do that made you think that?

Concerns

  • What, if anything, worries you?
  • Could a second interview or a task settle it?

The other candidates

  • How do they compare with the others you've seen?

Pay, notice and start date

  • Does their pay expectation work for you?
  • Does their notice period fit your start date?

The next step

  • What happens next, who will they meet, and when?
  • When will you decide?

What you can tell the candidate

  • What can I pass on to them, in your words?

If a reason touches on something the Equality Act 2010 protects, such as age, pregnancy or disability, steer back to what the job needs. A note like that can be used as evidence in a discrimination claim, and it isn't something you can pass on.

How do you run the feedback call?

Book it at the intake. Agree when you'll call: the same day as each interview, ideally within a few hours, while the detail is fresh.

Speak to whoever decides. If two people interviewed, ask whether they've compared notes. Feedback from a panel that hasn't talked yet can change by the next morning.

Start with the verdict. It tells you how long the call needs to be and which questions matter.

Ask for evidence until you get it. "Good communicator" becomes useful when you ask "What did she say that made you think that?". Keep going until each reason is something the candidate said or did.

The first note of the hiring manager’s feedback on the second candidate, marked up during the call: the verdict got its reasons, and the comment that wasn’t about the job came out.

Check concerns before the candidate hears them. A concern can be a misunderstanding you can clear up: the candidate may have answered a question about budgets with the wrong example. Ask whether the next stage could test it.

Agree what you'll pass on. Read back what you'll tell the candidate, so the hiring manager knows what they'll hear.

Write it up straight away, and send a short recap. The verdict, the next step and the date, in writing, stop the process drifting.

A woman with long dark wavy hair, in a white top, writes in a red notebook at a busy office desk, with a laptop, a desk phone, a calculator and a row of blue binders beside her.
Write the feedback up while the call is fresh, then send the hiring manager a two-line recap. Photo: Anna Tarazevich, Pexels.

Interview feedback example

Leah Simmons, an agency recruiter in London, put three candidates forward for an office manager job at a 60-person law firm in Holborn. The firm's operations director, Helen Carter, interviewed two of them with the managing partner on Thursday 26 November 2026. Leah rang Helen at 4:30 the same afternoon. These are her notes on the first candidate.

Interview feedback
Feedback from

Helen Carter, operations director

Candidate

Natalie Brooks

Role

Office manager, law firm in Holborn

Interview stage

First interview, with Helen and the managing partner

Date

26 November 2026, 16:30

Verdict

Second interview. "The best of the two so far." Fairly sure: wants to test one thing first.

Against the must-haves
  • An office of 40 or more: runs a 55-person office at an engineering consultancy in Farringdon.
  • Suppliers and the office budget: manages the cleaning, catering and IT contracts, but on a budget of about £180,000, not the £250,000 here.
  • Managing a small team: manages a receptionist and two facilities assistants.
  • An office move: ran her firm's move to a new floor in 2025, "on time, and she knew the cost of every line".
What impressed them

How she talked about the move: she had the plan and the budget to hand without being asked.

Concerns

The bigger budget, and she hasn't worked at a law firm. Helen thinks a second interview can test the budget; law firm experience was a nice-to-have, not a must.

Compared with others

Ahead of the other candidate seen today. The third candidate interviews on Monday.

Pay and package

Her £46,000 is within the £42,000 to £48,000 range.

Notice and start date

One month's notice fits a January start.

Next step

Second interview with the managing partner and the finance director, Tuesday 1 December at 10:00: a 20-minute walk through how she'd plan next year's office budget. Decision by Friday 4 December.

Feedback for the candidate

They liked how you ran the office move, and want to talk through budgets at the second interview.

Leah rang Natalie that evening with the feedback and the second interview, and sent Helen a two-line recap with the date.

Interview feedback template

One page per candidate, in the order of the call. Write the must-haves from the intake under "Against the must-haves" before you dial. It also works as an interview feedback form for a hiring manager who would rather write it down: send it to them after the interview. Download the Word file, free and with no sign-up, or copy it as text into your own document.

Interview feedback
Feedback from

[name, job title]

Candidate

[name]

Role

[job title, company]

Interview stage

[first, second or final]

Date

[date]

Verdict
  • Another interview, an offer, or a no?
  • How sure are they?
Against the must-haves
  • What did they see for each must-have?
  • Where was the evidence thin?
What impressed them
  • What stood out, and what did the candidate say or do?
Concerns
  • What worries them, and why?
  • Could the next stage test it?
Compared with others
  • How do they compare with the other candidates?
Pay and package
  • Does the candidate's expectation work?
Notice and start date
  • Does the notice period fit the start date?
Next step
  • What happens next, and when?
  • When will they decide?
Feedback for the candidate
  • What can we pass on, in their words?
Download the Word file.docx · opens in Word and Google Docs · no sign-up

If the feedback call runs through your computer, on Teams or a softphone, Sorinai fills in your feedback sheet as the hiring manager talks, and the Word file is ready a few minutes after you hang up. You can ask it to draft the note to the candidate from the call, and nothing goes to anyone until you send it. Tell the hiring manager at the start that the call is being recorded, as recording candidate calls explains.

Passing feedback on to the candidate

Call the candidate the same day, with the hiring manager's reasons in their words. For a second interview, say what impressed them and what the next stage will test, so the candidate can prepare. For a no, give the reasons that are about the job, and one thing they did well.

The second candidate Helen saw was a no: he had run a smaller office and hadn't managed anyone yet. This is how Leah put it to him:

Feedback to an unsuccessful candidate
Example

Daniel, thanks for going in on Thursday. They won't be taking it further, and I wanted to tell you why.

They need someone who has run an office of 40 or more and managed a team, and they felt your experience so far is with smaller offices.

They were impressed by the £30,000 a year you saved on supplier contracts, and said so.

I'd like to keep you in mind for office manager jobs at smaller firms. Is that OK?

Don't pass on anything you wouldn't want quoted back. In the UK a candidate can ask for a copy of what was written about them, from the agency as well as the employer, with a subject access request.

Interview feedback FAQ

How soon should you get feedback after an interview?

The same day if you can: a hiring manager who gives feedback within a few hours remembers the detail. Agree the time at the intake, and chase the next morning if it hasn't come.

What if the hiring manager just says "not the right fit"?

Ask what they saw: "What would the right person have said or done differently?" If it's still vague, go through the must-haves one by one. If no reason comes back, tell the candidate honestly that the client didn't give detailed feedback, rather than inventing one.

Should interview feedback be in writing?

Write up the call either way, and send the hiring manager a short recap so the verdict and the next step are agreed. Written notes are also what you'd show if a decision were challenged.

Does an employer have to give interview feedback?

In the UK, no law says an employer has to give a candidate feedback. But a candidate can ask for the notes made about them with a subject access request, so write feedback as if they'll read it.

Is an interview feedback form the same as a scorecard?

They're close. A scorecard rates each criterion, often from 1 to 5, and the interviewer fills it in. This template is for the recruiter's call: the verdict and the reasons in the hiring manager's words, which is what you need to pass on.

The Sorinai team
Written by
The Sorinai team
Read next
Reference check questions: script, email, example and template